評審講評
Comments
週期本身是能夠表達一個結構物運動基本行為的重要資訊，就像人的個性，需要先知道週期，才會了解結構物受外力作用後的表現，當我們要做很複雜的結構動力分析之前，最根本的就是要找出週期。如果同學進行了完整的實驗探索，就會很清楚知道你們量測的結果沒有很接近理論公式。我覺得這是一個很好的學習經驗，如果你發現結果與理論有誤差，就要去思考它的原因，讓結果更合理。實驗上本身非常不容易，因為有非常多的地方會造成誤差，其實我們沒有要求同學做出來的結果要跟理論公式一樣，同學還是很努力地找出了它的趨勢，我覺得這已經達到我們的期望。整體而言大家都掌握了比賽的精神，雖然主軸是結構安全，美觀的部分同學們也盡其所能的依你們的建築模型做非常多的詮釋，實驗上也達到我們的期待，非常不容易，也非常了不起。
劉光晏 老師
Period is an important information that can express the basic behavior of a structure's movement. Just like human emotions, you need to know the period before you understand the behavior of the structure under the action of external force. Before we do a very complex structural dynamic analysis, the most fundamental thing is to find the period. If the you have conducted a complete experimental exploration, you will know very well that the results of your measurements are not very close to the theoretical formula. I think this is a good learning experience, if you find that the results are inconsistent with the theory, you have to think about the reasons for it and make the results more reasonable. It is not easy, because there are many parts that could cause errors. In fact, we did not require the results of the students to be the same as the theoretical formulas. The students still worked hard to find its trend. I think this has reached our goal. On the whole, everyone has mastered the spirit of the competition. Although it is mainly about structural safety, the students also tried their best to interpret the aesthetic part according to your structural model, and the experiment also met our expectations. Very outstanding and very remarkable.
Assoc. Prof. Kuang-Yen, Liu
冠軍: 瑞芳高工(Kong fang)
Champian: Jui-Fang Industrial High School(Kong fang)
我可以看到他們的用心，結果相當豐富，數據也相當合理，這組佔優勢的部分是最後有把週期的公式做出來，透過實驗把結果展現出來，從數據上看起來是蠻漂亮的，這是他們比較特別的地方，對一個高中生來說，這已經是做得相當好
許瑞榮 老師
I can see their intentions, the results are quite rich, and the data is quite reasonable. The dominant part of this group is the exploration of the periodic formula, and the results are displayed through experiments. The data looks pretty good. For high school students, this has been done quite well
Prof. Rue-Ron, Hsu
亞軍: 精誠高中(Rome Hotel)
2nd place winner: Ching Cheng High School (Rome Hotel)
他們的建築:「Rome hotel」和羅馬連結在一起，我們很容易理解他們作品所要傳達的意思。我最感動的部分就是他們探討週期的過程，我覺得他們觀察入微，量測出來發現誤差後，開始去討論為什麼會有這些差異存在，他們發現了可能的問題，就去思考如何改善，讓量測值更合理
施忠賢 結構技師
Their architecture: "Rome hotel" is linked to Rome, and it is easy to understand what their work is trying to convey. The part that touched me the most was the process of their discussion of the period. I think they were very careful. After they found errors in their measurements, they began to discuss why these differences exist. When they found possible problems, they began to think about how to improve and let the measurement more reasonable.
SE. Dr. JUSTIN Chung-Hsien, Shih
季軍: 竹北高中(溪畔旅宿)
3rd place winner: Chupei Senior High School (Creekside Inn)
無論是外觀設計、灰色的木頭質感、以及內部的裝潢，旅社的家具都非常擬真，我們覺得非常具有代表性，再來是有關振動週期的量測，他們的實驗也是非常完整，探討斜撐與否、平行方向與垂直方向等變因
李孟學 老師
Whether it is the exterior design, the grey wood texture, and the interior decoration, the furniture of the hotel is very realistic, which we think is very representative, and the measurement of the vibration period, their experiments are also very complete. Whether bracing or not, parallel direction and vertical direction, etc.